William L. Pfeifer, Jr.

Alabama Appellate Lawyer with a Statewide Appellate Law Practice

  • Home
  • Blog
  • About Bill Pfeifer
  • Contact
  • Appeals
    • Criminal Appeals
    • Civil Appeals
    • Divorce Appeals
    • Personal Injury
  • Referrals
  • Legal Forms
  • Law Links
  • FAQS
You are here: Home » Blog » Appeals » Hearsay in Probation Revocation Cases – Admissible but Not Enough

Hearsay in Probation Revocation Cases – Admissible but Not Enough

January 23, 2011 by William L. Pfeifer, Jr.

An issue that comes up fairly often in probation revocation cases in Alabama is the use of hearsay evidence. Criminal defense lawyers often get confused about the role of hearsay in a probation revocation hearing because hearsay evidence is admissible. While hearsay is inadmissible in most settings, a judge has the discretion to listen to hearsay evidence as part of probation revocation proceedings if he or she chooses to allow it. But that is not the end of the argument, and it is at this point that attorneys often screw up the case. The issue is not the admissibility of the hearsay testimony, but whether it can be used to revoke probation. The short answer is that it can’t.

Just because hearsay is admissible into evidence in a probation revocation hearing does not mean it is sufficient for revoking probation. Alabama appellate courts have repeatedly held that hearsay testimony, by itself, is not enough to revoke a person’s probation. In the case of Armstrong v. State, 312 So. 2d 620 (Ala. 1975), the Alabama Supreme Court set the guidelines which must be followed in order to provide a probationer with minimal due process. Among those guidelines were the requirement of “the right to confront and cross-examine adverse witnesses (unless the judge specifically finds good cause for not allowing confrontation.)” Id. at 623. While  it is in the judge’s discretion to admit hearsay evidence in probation revocation hearings, hearsay cannot serve as the sole basis for revocation of a defendant’s probation. Ex parte Belcher, 556 So. 2d 366 (Ala. 1989).

Despite this rule, judges frequently revoke probation based solely on hearsay testimony, and too often criminal defense lawyers let them get away with it. Most of the time, it is simply because the lawyers don’t know the law on this issue. For those attorneys who are familiar with the restrictions on the use of hearsay in probation revocation proceedings, this is a great issue to argue to the trial judge or to raise in appeal to the Alabama appellate courts.

I’ve previously written about this subject in an article on page 7 of the 2007 issue of The Guardian (the newsletter of the Alabama Criminal Defense Lawyers Association) and in an article for Suite101.com in 2008. I’ll probably post an updated article to this site in the near future about some of the changes that have happened in probation law, but the law regarding the use of hearsay as cited in those articles is still correct.

If you are currently appealing a probation revocation case, make sure that your attorney raises this issue if the probation revocation was based on hearsay evidence. If you have not yet hired an attorney to handle the appeal, feel free to call our office at (800) 737-3702 Ext. 1 or send an email through our contact page.

Alabama State Bar rules require the following disclaimer in all attorney advertisements: “No representation is made that the quality of legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of services provided by other attorneys.”

Enhanced by Zemanta

Filed Under: Appeals, Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure Tagged With: Alabama, Alabama Supreme Court, Guardian, Hearsay, law, Lawyer, Probation, Revocation

Search

Recent Posts

  • Can you impeach your own witness in Alabama? Rule 607 provides the answer.
  • Hurricane Irma Courthouse Closures
  • Drug Forfeiture Appeals – Car forfeiture reversed based on innocent owner defense
  • Alabama Forfeiture Statute – Ala. Code Section 20-2-92 Drug Crime Forfeitures
  • Motion for Mistrial for undisclosed evidence in Alabama felony cases must be timely made
  • Alabama prison rape, violence, overcrowding, and abuse investigated by Department of Justice (DOJ)
  • Motion to continue trial due to an absent or unavailable witness – appealing the denial of a continuance in Alabama criminal court cases (video)
  • Alabama appellate lawyer video – new video on Alabama appeals added to YouTube
  • Alabama ‘McLendon standard’ in child custody modification appeals
  • AAJ Paralegal of the Year Award – Nominations Now Open

Avvo

Lawyer William Pfeifer | Top Attorney Appeals

Alabama Appellate Lawyer on Facebook

Alabama Appellate Lawyer

Archives

Categories

  • About.com
  • Appeals
  • Books
  • Business
  • Civil Procedure
  • Crime
  • Criminal Law
  • Criminal Procedure
  • Drug Crimes
  • Evidence
  • Family Law
  • Forfeiture
  • Immigration
  • Juveniles
  • Law Practice Management
  • Lawyer Referral Services
  • Legal Forms
  • Legal News
  • Legal Research
  • Legal Resources
  • Motions
  • Office Updates
  • Sex Crimes
  • Statutes
  • Technology
  • Video
  • Website

AVVO

Lawyer William Pfeifer | Top Attorney Appeals

Follow Us On Facebook

Alabama Appellate Lawyer

Tags

Alabama Alabama courthouse Alabama courthouse photos Alabama Court of Civil Appeals Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals Alabama forfeiture Alabama Rules of Criminal Procedure Alabama State Bar Alabama Supreme Court Appeal Appeals and Writs Appellate court Boglin Closing argument conviction Criminal Law Criminal Procedure divorce drug forfeiture effective assistance of counsel Examiner.com felony conviction Florida guilty plea ineffective assistance of counsel law Lawyer Lawyers and Law Firms legal forms legal research legal resources legal writing Plea post-conviction Practice of law Rule 32 Services Strickland Strickland v Washington Supreme Court Trial court United States United States Supreme Court updates Website

Pages

  • *WP Mobile Edition (Blog Index)
  • *WP Mobile Edition (Contact)
  • About Bill Pfeifer
  • Alabama Appellate Attorney
  • Alabama Appellate Lawyer
  • Alabama Civil Appeals Lawyer
  • Alabama Civil Litigation
  • Alabama Divorce Appeal Lawyer
  • Alabama Legal Forms
  • Alabama Personal Injury Lawyer – Litigation and Appeals
  • Appeals
  • Appellate Criminal Defense
  • Areas of Practice
  • Articles Elsewhere
  • Blog
  • Books
  • Contact
  • Family Law
  • FAQS – Frequently Asked Questions
  • Law Links Directory
  • Legal Forms
  • Newsletter
  • Office Locations
  • Payment
  • Privacy Policy
  • Referrals from Lawyers

Copyright © 2018 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in